Assisted suicide is when someone is provided with the means (drugs or equipment) to commit suicide. The controversial topic is usually aroused when discussing someone who is clearly on their way to death; possibly a very painful one. Should victims of AIDS or cancer or other plagues and illnesses suffer the wrath of their worsening condition? Should they be allowed to kill themselves painlessly before their progressive state plunges them into a bath of agony?
Many places allow assisted suicide with certain laws in place. A retired Norwegian physician, Christian Sandsdalen, had his medical license revoked after he admitted giving a morphine overdose to a woman suffering from MS (multiple sclerosis), a condition where the immune system attacks the central nervous system, damaging the spinal cord and brain; physical abilities and cognitive abilities (the way the brain processes information) begin to fade away. He was not put in jail, but had his license revoked. In Finland, there have been many cases where someone’s friend or family member assists in their suicide. They simply inform law enforcement officials and nothing more is done. Germany has no penalty for assisted suicide. Neither does France, nor Denmark, nor Scotland. In many places there are just simply no laws dealing with the issue. No law of the land. Law of the Bible or any other religious text, however, may play a large role in such acts.
The Bible states that one must repent (ask for forgiveness) for the sins that they commit. But if you commit suicide, you’re already dead, so you can’t ask for forgiveness. For those who believe in the Bible, it is said that those who commit suicide go to hell. But what about the people who assisted in the suicide? They can repent. Can’t they? Can they repent for playing the role of God himself?
Whether you believe the Christian faith or not, the U.S. law was formed around it. When you go to church, you must swear upon the Holy Bible that your testimony is valid. So it is sensible to speak about whether or not it is proper to “play God” when discussing such a controversial issue in America. Should anyone be allowed to play the role of God? Is helping someone end their suffering playing God? Is it just out of sheer love?
Would you assist in the suicide of your mother? What if she begged and pleaded you to “..help set her free..”? Could you aid her in suicide then? What about a mother to her children? Ask Carol Carr, age 61.
Carr, an American woman from Georgia, assisted in the suicide of her two sons, Michael, age 42, and Andy, age 41. The two brothers both fell ill to Huntington’s Diease.
This is an inherited genetic neurological disorder. The brain’s huntingtin gene normally provides information to produce the huntingtin protein. When affected, the gene produces a mutant protein resulting in an increase rate of neuronal cell death. This leads to the lack of neurological functions. Physically, victims will display uncontrollable, random jerking movements. Cognitively, victims will begin to lose the ability of planning and memory loss, both short term and long term appear over time. Psychiatrically, the victim will become anxious, depressed, egocentric, aggressive, and may develop many other unfortunate characteristics. With serious progression, patients mentally become different people, and become physically disabled. She shot her two terminally ill sons in June of 2002 and was sentenced to five years in prison.
Should assisted suicide be allowed? If so, who should be allowed to assist? Can murderers be let off of possible punishment by saying that they assisted in suicide of another? Is it ethical? Is it moral? Is it playing with fire, or playing the role of God? Should assisted suicide be allowed with strict government regulation? Could the government successfully regulate assisted suicide? Is it the governments decision? Is it your decision; my decision; God’s decision? Who decides? For more information visit assistedsuicide.org